Why old contracts stop working when vendors use AI
- Time and materials: if AI makes the vendor faster, the vendor bills fewer hours or keeps the gain. You cannot see which.
- Fixed price: the vendor keeps all the AI gain, and the scope fights stay.
- Story points: each team sizes them differently, so you cannot compare vendors.
The 4 KPIs to put in the contract
| KPI | What it shows | How to measure it |
|---|---|---|
| Delivered work per month | What the vendor finished | Score merged pull requests and closed tickets by size and difficulty |
| Cost per delivered point | What each unit of work cost | Invoice for the period divided by delivered points |
| Rework | If the work holds | Share of delivered work that is reverted or fixed again within 30 days |
| Share of work by AI agents | How much of the gain comes from AI | Delivered points from agents divided by all delivered points |
Add 2 rules: the data comes from the code and tickets, not from vendor reports, and both sides see the same dashboard.
How to renegotiate in 4 steps
- Measure 2 to 3 months first. Get the baseline: delivered work, cost per point and rework, before you talk.
- Change the unit. Move from hours to a price per delivered point, with a quality floor.
- Share the AI gain. Agree that a lower cost per point gives a lower price for you and a better margin for the vendor.
- Review every quarter. Compare the vendor with your in-house teams and your other vendors on the same scale.
See how to price software outsourcing when AI agents write code for the vendor side of the same change.
Common mistakes
- Asking for a discount without data. The vendor answers with its own numbers.
- Counting AI use as a KPI. Prompts and seats are activity, not delivered work.
- No quality floor. A price per unit without a rework limit rewards fast, weak work.
How Pensero measures vendor KPIs
The Delivery Point is one unit of finished work, scored by size and difficulty, the same way for vendors, in-house teams and AI agents. Pensero reads it next to cost and quality, and traces it to the pull request and ticket behind it.
- See Pensero for service firms and the current pricing.
- Book a scoping session to set your contract KPIs on one scale.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Which KPIs should a software outsourcing contract include?
Delivered work per month, cost per delivered point, rework, and the share of work done by AI agents, all measured from the code and the tickets.
Should we pay our vendor for AI agent hours?
No. Pay for delivered work. Agent hours, like human hours, show effort, not output.
How do we renegotiate when the vendor uses AI?
Measure the baseline for 2 to 3 months, move to a price per delivered point with a quality floor, and agree how to share the AI gain.
Which tool measures vendor KPIs on one scale?
Pensero measures the delivered work of vendors, in-house teams and AI agents on one scale, the Delivery Point, with cost and quality for each.
